What is the Canvas Space Is On?

When making a post, please ensure it complies with this site's Main Rules at all times.
  • What is Space actually made of?

    I mean what is the basic structure the energy and matter are on. What is the canvas?

    I do not mean the atoms, dark matter, baryonic matter, planets, dust, moons, or plasma that make up the Universe?

    I mean what is holding these physical structures of mass and energy.

    I am specifically talking about what the matter and energy is in or on.

    Like if you see a painting or drawing. You look at what the drawing is of.

    But what is the ink or paint on? What is the canvas made of?

    The question we need to ask ourselves is what are we as mass, such as the planets, and the vacuum of space on?

    For instance we are 1 astronomical unit from the Sun.

    We are 150 million kilometres from the Sun.

    And some would say there is nothing between the Earth and the Sun. Just a near perfect vacuum, with virtually nothing between us.

    But that is not what I am asking. I am asking what is holding that vacuum. On another level what is the vacuum of 150 million miles on.

    You cannot have 150 million miles of nothing. I know you will say it is a vacuum. But what is that vacuum on.

    I mean if you had a mile of space on Earth. Yes it might be containing matter, such as oxygen, rocks, oceans, clouds, humans, animals, and plants. But if you had a mile of outer space. There might be a near perfect vacuum. But it is still 1 mile of space. The same distance both times.

    So the thing is. Surely the 1 mile of near perfect space and 1 mile of Earth, are the same distance. So what is holding that 1 miles of space whether it be a near perfect vacuum or as on Earth containing huge amounts of matter.

    The actual structure that holds 1 mile of vacuum space and 1 mile of matter, must be the same thing,

    So what is that is holding the 1 mile of space and 1 mile of Earth matter.

    I know the Universe contains mass, energy, matter. But what is it on?

    This is a vital philosophical and scientific question.

    1 mile of mass and 1 mile of space vacuum, are both the same distance. What are they both on?

    It is as if we are people painted on a canvas that tells a story or landscape. On one level you can as an art critic try to explain the story that the painting is telling. But to make that work of art you must know what we are made. Are we paint, or are we layers of different paint on a canvas? And what is that canvas made of? A canvas with no paint on it, is the same distance as a canvas with art on it.

  • I have always wondered why don't planets just fall?

    If the planets are in nothing (space) then what is keeping them in place?

    I don't know what the canvas/vacuum is on, or what is keeping it in place, but I wish it could be figured out. I suspect there are invisible "strings" outside our dimension holding the canvas in place, but it's an interesting question, isn't it?

    Great topic. 8) :thumbup:

  • I have always wondered why don't planets just fall?

    Strictly speaking the planets ARE falling all the time towards the sun, they are also in orbit which produces centripetal acceleration away from the sun. As these two are in balance the planets just go round and round. The same way our moon is in orbit round the Earth.

    History is much like an Endless Waltz. The three beats of war, peace and revolution continue on forever.


  • So, are we gradually moving closer to the Sun or away from it, as time goes on?

    As long as the sun's gravity remains constant we will continue to orbit in the same path as will the other planets. Should that gravity change then our orbit would alter the keep things in balance.

    A different situation exists with the Earth and our moon: Because the moon raises tides on the Earth and these tides are carried forward by the Earths rotation and slightly lead the Moon, this produces a gravitational force that is accelerating the moon. The result is that is very slowly pushing the moon further away from us.

    There are also more interesting consequences of orbital mechanics such as in the five Lagrange points. L4 and L5 in the Earth / moon system are interesting if we want space colonies as they are unconditionally stable and an object placed there remains in the same point.

    History is much like an Endless Waltz. The three beats of war, peace and revolution continue on forever.


Participate now!

Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!